Sunday, June 23, 2019

Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone (2001, Review #2)

While I've reviewed these movies before, it was before I read the books and I feel as though they warrant a revisit. Now, in this set of reviews I'll struggle a little to limit myself strictly to the films. I will readily admit that I've read the books at least a half a dozen times. I listen to the audiobook version every year, primarily in the summer while I'm working and can listen to each book in about a weeks time, often less. I've enjoyed revisiting this franchise time and time again and there is plenty to gain from it on repeat viewing/listening/reading. As my nieces and nephews get older it's fun and entertaining to watch as they read the books and then get to experience the movies. I've even started listening to a podcast about the Harry Potter books wherein the hosts discuss the books chapter by chapter. While this seems like it might be tedious, I've enjoyed it. I started listening when the podcast is in book five, while I haven't gone back and listened to the entire series I may have to go back and listen to the episodes about book four, since that's my favorite. If you have never read the books, I must recommend that you read the books before rewatching these films. It really adds another element to the experience, and it also adds to the plots of each film. And this starts to touch on my biggest gripe about these movies. As is a common occurrence in book-to-screen adaptations, the books were better. It's not just that the books were better though, it's that it seems as though it would have been fairly easy to include more of what was in the book into the movies. What may have taken a few paragraphs, or a even a page, in the book can be covered in a matter of seconds as a bit of a scene change, or scene intro, in the movies. In many instances though, these quick shots would have covered plot points that become more important in hindsight through the books. In some instances the movies actually go to the effort of recreating, or altering a scene to accomplish the same thing the books did in a shorter period of time. That being said, as the films were being made it was a different beast/task. The books weren't complete when they started the films, the success of the film franchise wasn't guaranteed at the beginning, etc. There's plenty of material here though and I have a feeling that as the years progress we will see more and more things that make the books their source material. I could even envision a tv series that makes each chapter, or a couple of chapters, into a single episode. The show could run for a long time and would pose significant challenges to shoot, but could be tremendous fun. That's a terribly long intro to a single film, so I'll get on with it. Now as we discuss the first film in the franchise let's set aside all of my previous gripes and put this into context. The first book was released in 1997. It quickly began to gain traction and fans. The second book came out in 1997, the third was released in 1999, and the fourth in 2000. So at the time this film was released in 2001 only four books had been written and released. The film had significant challenges and hurdles to overcome. One could speculate that had this film flopped it could have easily damaged the full series of the movies. It could have also damaged the book series, but by book four the books series seemed pretty secure. Alas though, the film had a $90,000,000 opening weekend in the US. Its budget was an estimated $125,000,000. It grossed over $317,000,000 in the US box office. I've seen figures that estimate over $974,000,000 worldwide gross, but that was only through 2011. This film starts with the story plot of Harry, essentially serving as a slave to the family of his maternal Aunt Petunia. Soon though, Harry discovers that he's a wizard! He receives an invite to attend Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. There's extended scenes of his Aunt and Uncle trying to prevent him from learning of this, and trying to prevent him from attending the school. Then we receive our introduction to the Hogwarts. In modern viewings we have to be a little forgiving and remember that this was 2001, that the film franchise wasn't guaranteed, the books weren't complete, etc. Even the director, Christopher Columbus has said he regrets some of the special effects. We didn't know where the story would eventually go, we didn't know what this would grow to be, there was a lot that wasn't known. Perhaps in spite of all of that, this film still does it's job fairly well. We are introduced to the main characters to the plot of the series, we get to know our protagonists, we get our first introduction to Lord Voldemort, and our first confrontation between the Dark Lord and Harry Potter. One often overlooked part of this book/film is details about Nicholas Flamel, the creater of the Sorcerer's (Or Philosopher's) Stone. Nicholas Flamel is reference in many other pop culture films and books. Nicholas Flamel may have been a real alchemist who was born in France around 1330. There was mysterious circumstances around his death in 1418 that led to the rumors he lived for hundreds of years. Both the book and the movie get Flamel's age right. While this is my least favorite of the films, and I don't watch it every time I come back to this series, it is still good. And if you're reading the books for the first time it would be critical to rewatch the movie after completing the book. If you were trying to squeeze a Harry Potter marathon into a day, it could easily be skipped. Any gripes about this movie should be set aside though. For what the franchise was when it was produced, it's a good film, bordering on great. While I only rate it 6 out of 10 stars (The book gets a better rating, but still not perfect), it's a critical part of the cannon that shouldn't be overlooked.

No comments: